Organizing a Group Gift Exchange?
Here’s How GiftHub Makes It Effortless

Sam Martineau

March 21, 2025

couple exchanging gifts


Group gift exchanges are one of my favorite parts of the holidays but they can be messy and difficult to organize. Here’s how I used Gifthub this year to simplify my family’s “Secret Santa” gift exchange.



The Traditional Method


Gathering at Mom and Dad’s


For years, our family stuck to the same Secret Santa setup. A few weeks before Christmas, we’d all meet up at my parents’ house. It was a warm, familiar tradition we looked forward to.


Making the Name Cards


We’d start by grabbing some 3x5 cards. Everyone wrote their name and a couple of gift ideas, then dropped them into a bowl. It was a simple way to get things going.


Drawing Names


Next, the bowl went around the room. You’d pick a card when it reached you, and that name was your gift recipient. On paper, it seemed like a perfect plan.


The Catch


At first, it worked like a charm. But as our family got bigger and schedules tightened, the whole thing started to falter. Simple didn’t mean foolproof anymore.



Challenges of Traditional Gift Exchanges


Although our traditional way of gift exchanging has worked for our family for years, it hasn't come without it's challenges. Here's why we decided to ditch the old-school approach this year:


1. Coordinating Everyone in One Place is Nearly Impossible


Getting the whole family together in one location used to be a breeze when we were young. We'd simply pile into my parents living room a few weeks before chirstmas and boom! That was it. But now? It's a different story. Some siblings are married, others are living out of the country and one is in the military. Trying to get everyone together for a group gift exchange is logistically impossiple at this year. The traditional way of passing a bowl of 3 x 5 cards around the living room simply won't cut it.


2. The Awkward ‘Pick Your Own Name’ Mishap


Even when we manage to gather, the process hits another snag: someone inevitably pulls their own name from the bowl. It’s a small thing, but it throws everything off. We have to toss all the cards back in, shake it up, and start over—hoping it doesn’t happen again. It’s a silly hiccup, but it wastes time and tests everyone’s patience.


3. Lost Papers Throw Everything Off


The biggest headache with the traditional method? Someone always forgets the details. A week after the draw, you’re almost guaranteed to hear, “Wait, who did I get again?” or “What were their gift ideas?” In the whirlwind of holiday prep with shopping, decorating, and wrapping, those little 3x5 cards don’t stand a chance. Without a reliable way to keep track of names and wishlists, the whole system unravels.



These challenges made it clear: the traditional method wasn’t going to work for our family this time. That’s why this year, we ditched the bowl and turned to a digital wishlist app, GiftHub.



How GiftHub Turns Chaos into Convenience


Ready for a change, we turned to GiftHub. Here’s how this wishlist app made our group gift exchange effortless:


Getting Started with GiftHub


We kicked things off by signing up for free at gifthub.me. The process was quick and simple, no complicated steps or fees. Within minutes, we were ready to dive in and set up our exchange.


Creating and Sharing Wishlists


Next, we each created our own wishlists. GiftHub makes this part a breeze. You can search the internet for gift ideas, copy a link, and paste it right into your list. Want a new book from Amazon or a cozy sweater from your favorite store? Just add the link, and it’s there. We loved how easy it was to build a list that reflected exactly what we wanted. Then, we connected as friends by sharing our unique “friend codes,” which you can find in the profile section. It’s a simple way to link up with everyone in the group.


Setting Up the Exchange


With our lists ready, it was time to organize the exchange. GiftHub’s tools made this the smoothest part yet. Here’s how it works:


1. Open the app and select “Exchange” from the menu.

GiftHub App Menu


2. Create and name your exchange, like “Family Secret Santa 2025.”

GiftHub App Create Exchange


3. Click the “add people” icon to invite friends from your list.

GiftHub App Invite Friends to Exchange


4. Hit the “shuffle” button to randomly assign everyone a person.

GiftHub App Assign Exchange


5. Have each person upload their wishlist to the exchange, and you’re set!

GiftHub App Submit List


The app handles all the randomization, so there’s no risk of picking your own name. Plus, everything stays digital, so no one’s losing a scrap of paper.



Why GiftHub Wins Over Traditional Methods


This year, GiftHub saved our Secret Santa in ways the old bowl-and-cards method never could. We didn’t need to cram into one room, waste time restarting the draw, or scramble to remember lost details. The whole family was set up in minutes, no matter where we were. Plus, with everyone’s wishlists right there in the app, we all got gifts we actually wanted, no guesswork required.



Ready to Simplify Your Group Gift Exchange?


Group gift exchanges can be challenging to organize, but they don’t have to be. Whether it’s a family Secret Santa, an office holiday swap, or a friend group event, GiftHub offers a way to manage the process smoothly. If you’re considering a simpler approach, visit gifthub.me to sign up for free and set up your group gift exchange in minutes!